Many people believe that columbus day should not be celebrated because christopher columbus committed atrocities against native americans they argue that it creates a false narrative about the discovery of the americas and contributes to the disenfranchisement of native americans. Since then, efforts to eliminate or rename the columbus day holiday in various states and cities have met strong resistance from italian americans, who have said columbus is an important figure in. Columbus day has been a federal holiday since 1937, and here are some reasons why it probably shouldn't be john iadarola and hannah cranston discuss some shocking facts about christopher columbus. Columbus day, the second monday in october, is a nationally recognized holiday but it's not recognized in los angeles, where i live the city council recently voted to get rid of columbus day.
No to columbus day it is my belief that although many people celebrate the holiday of columbus day, that it should be celebrated because christopher columbus was not who he had seemed to be i have learned that not only did he not know where he was, but he wasn't even the first to discover the new world. Columbus day has long been celebrated without controversy, but recently, opponents say columbus shouldn't be honored due to his impact on native americans search the site go issues. Every october, the united states celebrates christopher columbus' discovering of the americas turns out, columbus wasn't such a stellar guy.
South dakota has celebrated native american day instead of columbus day since 1990 in 2014, seattle and minneapolis became the first major american cities whose city councils voted to approve a measure recognizing indigenous people's day. Before i get into the why we shouldn't celebrate columbus day, im going to explain why we do the first columbus day was celebrated in 1792 in order to remember the historical landing's 300th anniversary. Talk of an alternative columbus day dates back to the 1970s, writes nolan feeney for time, but the idea came to berkeley after the first continental conference on 500 years of indian.
We don't celebrate columbus day in this house, and we never will it's not that we don't enjoy holidays when they come around we love holidays around here as much as anyone, but there are some holidays that, in my opinion, should not be celebrated columbus day is one of those holidays i. Vermont, denver and phoenix join growing list of places celebrating native americans on the federal holiday named for christopher columbus. No, while it's nice to get a day off, we shouldn't celebrate the thing he didn't find the new america, but got the credit for it i read before he passed on, he confessed he wasn't the one who found the new land. Happy columbus day, for without his foresight, in all likelihood america as we know it would not exist, and might never have been given birth to the enlightened people who inhabit it today.
Columbus day should not be celebrated every year, on the second monday in october, the people in the united states celebrate a national holiday in memory of christopher columbus, the one who discovered the new continent. As most of us know -- there is no reason on the planet for the united states to observe at least two of its holidays -- columbus day and thanksgiving. Columbus day is a us holiday that commemorates the landing of christopher columbus in the americas in 1492, and columbus day 2018 occurs on monday, october 8 it was unofficially celebrated in a. Really, we shouldn't celebrate columbus day because columbus mistreated the native americans to work them as slaves before he got there, the native population was up to 3 million people with a good life that they lived. Many people don't even get the day off work, instead trading columbus day for the day after thanksgiving the holiday's popularity has been waning for some time.
Should americans celebrate columbus day on october 12, 1492, christopher columbus, a portuguese explorer, landed on an island near cuba, which he named san salvador it was the first time that europeans reached america, marking the beginning of contact between europe and the american continent. It doesn't make sense for the united states to recognize this supposed christian with a national holiday, so america should stop celebrating columbus day the initial recorded columbus day celebration in the united states was on october 12, 1792. If it weren't for columbus we wouldn't be here today of course we should celebrate columbus day we live in great country today columbus wasn't the first to discover america but he was the first to start an expedition and help us move here. Wikimedia since 1937, americans have celebrated columbus day on the second monday of october as part of a growing movement to abolish the holiday, nine new municipalities decided this year to.
On monday, americans across the country celebrate columbus day by remembering it exists, frantically trying to figure out if they have to go to work, and then being disappointed when they do. Columbus day has been a federal holiday since president franklin d roosevelt first proclaimed it such in 1934 one hundred years ago this month, colorado sen casimo barela's bill was signed.
The obvious reason not to celebrate columbus day is that he did not discover america any more than i discovered columbia the day in september 1960 when i first set foot on campus, the first of my friends from flushing to do so but there is also a serious reason beyond the murder of native. Some say columbus day shouldn't be celebrated because of the violence he inflicted upon the inhabitants of the lands he conquered, leaving a history of slavery in his wake. Columbus day, which is celebrated today in the usa and honours the arrival of christopher columbus to the 'new world', is an example of outdated and misguided history rather than celebrate, we believe it should be a day to mourn the destruction of an indigenous population which had lived in peace for tens of thousands of years before. Debate on columbus day essay 918 words | 4 pages to change columbus day to no longer be a holiday would be turning a blind eye to a difficult history, yet still turning that eye away from a history with a side to be celebrated.